What changes the narrative?

4 posts / 0 new
Last post
James Powell's picture
Offline
Joined: May 7 2010
What changes the narrative?

This theme takes us outside PAC and PASCAL to ask how governance and opinion-forming occur nowadays. Who determines, and by what means how we think, what we believe and take for granted, what is on and off the agenda? What terms that we use are taken for granted? Who outside the PASCAL community listens to our discourse about learning and learning cities, then how do they act on what it suggests? If so, is this possibly local, piecemeal and gradualistic action of a kind that becomes a critical mass? 

How much decision-making, and of the assumptions behind it, is transparent to everyone?  What remains closed to ordinary citizens? Can we uncover how political and cultural processes work today; and as the PASCAL Observatory work with the grain to get results

What is the immediate and short-term, and what the deeper impact and power of the social media; of older media, lobbyists and ‘captains of industry’, as well as press barons?  Does one medium and political channel trump the others?

Behind and beneath the hidden seats of power, is ‘civil society’ (CS) an engine for change, or just a sop?  How can civil society, and a network CS body like PASCAL, be most effective? We want to know how to turn what James Powell calls maturing conversation into effective action.  Can what we do help trigger a cultural paradigm shift whereby citizens and governing classes both see and act on the world differently?  

This is connected with a Theme found under Development, learning and management of place what many people see as a vital problem and challenge: 

Do local solutions help address the disillusion, even cynicism and crisis, of western democracy and leadership in this media and poll-driven era?

Ultimately all these questions connect in a complex  fragmented world outside each box; we hope to add to and apply better understanding of some key issues along the way.

 

Norman Longworth's picture
Offline
Joined: May 7 2010
Petition sites

What has changed my own ability to make my thoughts heard is the proliferation of petition sites over the past 2 years. Where I used to silently fume in frustration about the inhumanity of man to man I now find that I can join my voice to thousands, sometimes millions, of others who want to right an obvious wrong. Such sites as AVAAZ, Change.org, walk-free, care2, 38degrees  etc  address some of the planet's more visible atrocities on a variety of topics. It enfranchises me to know that the results will be presented to decision makers and sometimes make a difference. Forcing a rethink of the development of port Abbott in Queensland, stopping the incarceration, and sometimes execution, of journalists for broadcasting unpalatable truths, reducing modern slavery, encouraging humane treatment for animals in France, are some examples among many. They have certainly changed the narrative in those places where injustice was being perpetrated.

A word of caution though - they can be a double-edged sword. We need to be be careful what we choose to support and sure that what we are voting for is genuine and not just a personal vendetta or a means of halting progress. Be aware too that similar sites can advocate issues that are the opposite of what we might want to see happen.

This prompts me to wonder if PASCAL could adapt and adopt a similar tactic within some of its its areas of interest. Often we present information, ideas. knowledge, research without asking for a simple yes, no or maybe response from the reader with the opportunity to write a short comment. ̦Perhaps this is an idea which needs to be teased out, avoiding of course the trivialisation which social media sites like facebook often engender. How about the PASCAL Education and Learning Futures Site which addresses topical issues and invites readers to support change and to proliferate through twitter and facebook? Enlightening and enfranchising. And bringing PASCAL into the modern age. 

Norman

James Powell's picture
Offline
Joined: May 7 2010
OTB - a Petition site

I like Norman's idea of creating a petition site for key issues that need moving forward. I had hope, andd continue to hope, that discussion in the Forum would tease out things to make a real difference. We could then turn these issues into a new sub areas of OTB where we can get PASCAL to join other voices about what can be effectively changed and how best to do it. Perhaps, with Norman's knowledge of such sites he can set up a demonstration for us of how we should act to gain most impact.

James Powell's picture
Offline
Joined: May 7 2010
OTB - a Petition site

I like Norman's idea of creating a petition site for key issues that need moving forward. I had hope, andd continue to hope, that discussion in the Forum would tease out things to make a real difference. We could then turn these issues into a new sub areas of OTB where we can get PASCAL to join other voices about what can be effectively changed and how best to do it. Perhaps, with Norman's knowledge of such sites he can set up a demonstration for us of how we should act to gain most impact.

Syndicate content